MBSE Wiki

This page is read only. You can view the source, but not change it. Ask your administrator if you think this is wrong.
====== System of Systems/Enterprise Modeling ======
return to: [[http://www.omgwiki.org/MBSE/ |  MBSE Wiki Start]]

===== What's New - 2014 =====
  * SoS Architecture Framework Standards
      * [[http://www.omg.org/spec/UPDM/ | OMG UPDM Specifications]]
      * {{mbse:UPDM 3.0 RFP Sept.doc|OMG UPDM 3.0 RFP}}
      * [[mbse: MBSE Human View Modeling Standard | UPDM 3.0 Human View Modeling Discussion Topics ]]
  * Related Research Efforts
      *  {{http://compass.informatik.rwth-aachen.de/ | COMPASS - Correctness, Modeling and Performance of Aerospace Systems}}
      *  {{ https://www.danse-ip.eu/home/    |   DANSE - Designing for Adaptability and evolutioN in System of systems Engineering}}
      *  {{ https://engineering.purdue.edu/people/daniel.a.delaurentis.1/html/SoSL.html  |  Purdue University System of Systems Laboratory}}
  * Sos/EA Best Practice and Challenge Problem Areas
      *  {{ http://www.darpa.mil/Our_Work/TTO/Programs/Adaptive_Vehicle_Make__(AVM).aspx |  DARPA - Adaptive Vehicle Make Challenge }}

===== Welcome to the SoS/Enterprise Modeling Activity Wiki Page =====


Welcome to the SoS/Enterprise Modeling Activity Wiki page sponsored by the INCOSE MBSE initiative.

Please also join us in the LinkedIn group for INCOSE MBSE SoS Enterprise Architecture discussions at: [[http://www.linkedin.com/nus-trk?trkact=viewGroup&pk=group_most_popular&pp=2&poster=31716743&uid=5699570957316788224&ut=NUS_UNIU_NEWGROUP&r=&f=0&url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww%2Elinkedin%2Ecom%2Fgroups%3Fgid%3D4814096%26goback%3D%252Egmp_4814096%26trk%3DNUS_UNIU-ngroup&urlhash=qxom&goback=%2Egmp_4814096| MBSE SoS EA LinkedIn Group]]

**Note:**  This is an open group,  but requires LinkedIn registration...to gain access as a new member please register with LinkedIn (free basic membership) and link to the group above.

===== Purpose =====
The purpose of this activity is to foster interest and participation in the continuing efforts to model enterprise and system of systems level architecture specifications and frameworks.  The focus areas include the DoD  DODAF 2.0 MetaModeling, NATO NAF Modeling, UK MOD MODAF modeling, OMG UPDM 2.0, the BPMN and BPEL, SOAML, NDIA System of Systems committee efforts and NCOIC Network Centric patterns efforts.

Similar to the Systems Engineering initiatives to evolve away from document based descriptions of systems to a model base descriptions of systems,  the SoS/Enterprise modeling focus is on the efforts underway to evolve from a document only description of Architectures, Capabilities, Programmatics, etc. to a more rigorous model based representation of all the perspectives involved in engineering at the SoS and Enterprise levels of abstraction.


As discussed in the [[http://www.infoed.com/Open/PAPERS/systems.htm|Architecting Principles for System of Systems]] reference,  not all System of Systems are alike and come in three broad categories  Directed, Collaborative, Virtual with five principal characteristics:

  * Operational Independence of the Elements
  * Managerial Independence of the Elements
  * Evolutionary Development
  * Emergent Behavior
  * Geographic Distribution


===== Measure of Success ===== 
Engage the stakeholders, capture the stakeholder expectations and define the measures of success.

Some Examples of measures for our focus area:

^Measure^Description^
|Team Membership|Number of active team members contributing to Wiki Pages, Discussion Groups and Webinars|
|2011/2012 Webinars|Number of webinars in 2011/12 addressing SoS/Enterprise Modeling|
|Community Outreach|Number of references to INCOSE MBSE SoS/Enterprise Modeling in SE Literature|
|Publications|Number of publications by INCOSE MBSE SoS/Enterprise Modeling membership|

===== Topic Overview / Description =====
There are many definitions and interpretations of Systems of Systems and Enterprise level analysis, architecting and engineering.  For example,  one definition of System of Systems includes:  " a class of problems that have unique characteristics, distinguishing them from "classic" systems, for example, unbounded context and usage, potentially emergent behaviors, large number of complex interactions, costly to fully verify and validate a priori..."   These unique characteristics have lead the Systems Engineering and Architecting community to investigate new languages and frameworks to help better define these key System of Systems characteristics.\\
\\
===System of Systems Engineering===
T. Saunders, et al, in "United States Air Force Scientific Advisory Board Report on System of Systems Engineering for Air Force Capability Development" SAB-TR-05-04, July 2005 included the follow table:\\
\\

{{:mbse:systemsvssos.jpg|}}
\\
=== SoS Engineering Key Concepts ===

  *Legacy Systems
  *Dynamic Reconfiguration of Architecture
  *Service Oriented Architecture Enabler
  *Protocols and Standards to Enable Interoperable Systems
  *Added “ilities”  or Quality Attributes
  *Federated Acquisition 
  *Independent Systems
  *Concept of Operations Critical
  *Ongoing Experimentation
  *Converging Spirals

===System of System MBSE Implications===
{{:mbse:sos_mbse_small.jpg|}}

=====Schedule ===== 

^Date^Milestone^Status^Point of Contact^
|September, 2010|OMG UPDM 2.0 Submission|First UPDM 2.0 Submission|Matthew Hause, Atego; Jim Rice, NoMagic; Graham Bleakley, IBM|
|September, 2010|OMG Architecture Echosystem RFP|RFP Approval for Issuance|Cory Casanave, Model Driven Solutions|
|December, 2010|OMG Technical Meeting, Santa Clara, CA - UPDM 2.0 RTF Sessions|Completed|Matthew Hause, Atego; Jim Rice, NoMagic; Graham Bleakley, IBM|
|January/February, 2011|INCOSE IW Phoenix, AZ  MBSE Sessions|Completed|Sandy Friedenthal, LMCO|
|January, 2012|INCOSE IW Jacksonville, FL MBSE Sessions|Completed|Sandy Friedenthal|
|January, 2013|INCOSE IW Jacksonville, FL MBSE Sessions|Completed|Sandy Friedenthal|

==== Face to Face meetings ====
^Date^Meeting type^Participants^
|2010-07-12|OMG UPDM Team Meeting|Ron Williamson, Matthew Hause, Len Levine, Jim Rice|
|2012-Dec|OMG UPDM Team Meeting|Ron Williamson, Matthew Hause, UPDM Standards Team|
|2013-Jan|INCOSE MBSE Workshop - Jacksonville, FL| Ron Williamson, Matthew Hause, Charles Dickerson, Judith Dahmann, MBSE Team|

==== Webinars ====
^Date^Topic^Speaker^
|January, 2011|SoS/Enterprise Modeling Objectives| Ron Williamson|
|February, 2011|UPDM 2.0 Executive Summary| Matthew Hause|
|June, 2011|Multi Discipline Model Based Engineering| Ron Williamson|
|January, 2012|MBSE Architecture Framework Primer| Ron Williamson|
|September, 2012|MBSE Support for SoS "Pain Points"| Ron Williamson|

===== Team Members & SoS/Enterprise Modeling Subject Matter Experts ===== 

^Name^Organization^Contact Information^Role / Area of Expertise^
|Ron Williamson| Raytheon| ron_c_williamson@raytheon.com|Team Facilitator, MBE PI, SoS/EA Architect|
|Matthew Hause| Atego| matthew.hause@atego.com|Team Facilitator, Atego Tool Suite, OMG UPDM Co-Chair & AB Member|

^Name^Organization^Contact Information^Role / Area of Expertise^
|Leonard Levine |DoD | leonard.levine@disa.mil|DoDAF, CADM|
|Fatma Dandashi| Mitre |dandashi@mitre.org |DoDAF, Modeling & Simulation|
|Graham Bleakley | IBM | bleakley@ibm.com |IBM Rational Rhapsody Tool Suite,  OMG UPDM Co-Chair |
|Terri Wolfram| NASA | theresa.worlfrom@nasa.gov |NASA Enterprise Architecture Team|
|Judith Dahmann| Mitre |TBD |INCOSE SoS WG Co-Chair,  NDIA SoS WG Chair|
|Charles Dickerson |  Loughborough University |TBD |INCOSE Architecture WG Co-Chair|
|Lonnie Van Zandt | NoMagic | TBD | NoMagic Tool Suite , OMG UPDM Co-Chair |






===== Topics of Interest =====
Some of the key efforts underway related to SoS/Enterprise modeling including, 
  *OMG Unified Profile for DoDAF/MODAF (UPDM) standards [[http://www.updm.com/index.htm|UPDM Group]]
  *OMG Architecture Ecosystem Special Interest Group [[http://www.omgwiki.org/architecture-ecosystem/doku.php|AE SIG]]
  *Business Process Modeling [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Business_Process_Modeling_Notation|BPMN]]
  *Service Oriented Architecture modeling [[http://www.omgwiki.org/SoaML/doku.php|SOAML]]
  *IDEAS Group [[http://www.ideasgroup.org/|IDEAS Group Website]]
  *DoD DODAF 2.0 Meta Model [[http://cio-nii.defense.gov/sites/dodaf20/DM2.html|DM2 Website]]
  *UK MOD MODAF 1.2 Meta Model [[http://www.mod.uk/DefenceInternet/AboutDefence/CorporatePublications/InformationManagement/MODAF/ModafMetaModel.htm| M3 Website]]
  *NCOIC Netcentric Patterns [[https://www.ncoic.org/technology/deliverables/patterns/|Netcentric Patterns Website]]




===== Reference Document Library =====

    *{{:mbse:sos_se_guide_v1_0_working_draft.pdf|SoS SE Guide v1.0}}
    * What are the differences between a vocabulary, a taxonomy, a thesaurus, an ontology, and a meta-model? [[http://infogrid.org/wiki/Reference/PidcockArticle]]
    *{{:mbse:wg3_early_se.pdf|Early Systems Engineering - A Level of Analytical Fidelity to Support MDD and MS A Decisions}}

===== Reference Links ===== 
Link to related items such as related organizations, related articles, ...

====2011 International Workshop Slides====

  * {{:mbse:incose_iw_sos_project_plan_rev_a.pptx|2011 INCOSE SoS-Enterprise Modeling Workshop Agenda 2011}}
  * {{:mbse:2011_incose_mbse_sos_intro.ppt|2011 INCOSE MBSE SoS-Enterprise Modeling Introduction}}
  * {{:mbse:updm_update_incose_iw_30-jan-2011_m.hause_v1.ppt|2011 MBSE UPDM Introduction}}

====2012 International Workshop Slides====

  * {{:mbse:2012_incose_mbse_sos_intro.ppt|2012 INCOSE MBSE SoS-Enterprise Modeling Introduction}}


====2013 International Workshop Slides====

  * {{:mbse:2013_incose_mbse_sos_-_ea_activity_workshop_introduction.ppt|2013 INCOSE MBSE SoS-Enterprise Modeling Introduction}}

====2014 International Workshop SoS/Enterprise Architecture Modeling Plans====

  * Coordination with SoS Working Group...deferred until SoS WG interest in MBSE identified beyond current academic focus of the WG
  * Coordination with Architecture Working Group...added to 2014 WG follow up tasks with Charles Dickerson as Arch WG POC for MBSE liaison
  * Coordination with Human Systems Integration Working Group...possible interest on Human View Modeling for Architecture Frameworks

==== INCOSE Links ====


   *[[http://www.omgwiki.org/MBSE|INCOSE MBSE Initiative Wiki Home Page]]
   *[[http://www.incose.org/practice/techactivities/wg/sysarch/|INCOSE Architecture Working Group]]
   *[[http://www.incose.org/practice/techactivities/wg/details.aspx?id=asse|INCOSE Agile Systems & Systems Engineering Working Group]]
   *[[http://www.incose.org/practice/techactivities/wg/details.aspx?id=sos |INCOSE System of Systems Working Group]]
   *[[http://www.incose.org/practice/techactivities/wg/details.aspx?id=hsi |INCOSE Human Systems Integration Working Group]]
   *[[Start|MBSE SoS/EA Model Examples]]
   *[[Exchanges|MBSE SoS/EA Group Exchanges]]




=== Cross MBSE Team Links ===

  *[[http://www.omgwiki.org/MBSE/doku.php#challenge_teams|Challenge Teams]]

  *[[http://www.omgwiki.org/MBSE/doku.php?id=mbse:methodology|MBSE Methodology]]

  *[[http://www.omgwiki.org/MBSE/doku.php?id=mbse:ontology|MBSE Ontology]]

  *[[http://www.omgwiki.org/MBSE/doku.php?id=mbse:standards|Modeling Standards]]

  *[[http://www.omgwiki.org/MBSE/doku.php?id=mbse:usability|MBSE Usability]]




==== OMG Links ====

   *[[http://www.omg.org| Object Management Group Home Page]]
   *[[http://www.omgwiki.org/architecture-ecosystem|OMG Architecture EcoSystem Wiki Page]]
   *[[http://www.omgwiki.org/UPDMAlpha/doku.php|OMG Unified Profile for DoDAF/MODAF (UPDM)  Wiki Page]]
   *[[http://www.omg.org/spec/UPDM/2.0/|OMG UPDM 2.0 Specificiations]]

==== NDIA Links ====

   *[[http://www.ndia.org/|NDIA Home Page]]
   *[[http://www.ndia.org/Divisions/Divisions/SystemsEngineering/Pages/SystemsofSystemsCommittee.aspx|NDIA SoS Engineering Committee]]
   *[[http://www.ndia.org/Divisions/Divisions/SystemsEngineering/Pages/ArchitectureCommittee.aspx|NDIA Architecture Committee]]

==== Academia Links ====

   *[[http://www.mbse.gatech.edu/|Georgia Tech]]
   *[[http://www.ece.stevens-tech.edu/iNetS/index.html|Stevens Institute]]
   *[[ http://www.ncsose.org/|Old Dominion University]]
   *[[ https://engineering.purdue.edu/Engr/Research/Initiatives/SoS/| Purdue University]]
   *[[http://www.sei.cmu.edu/sos/research/|CMU]]
   *[[http://www.usc.edu/dept/ise/academics/graduate/sae.htm | USC ]]
   *[[https://www.uclaextension.edu/pages/Course.aspx?reg=Y0925   | UCLA]]


==== MBSE Related Graduate Courses ====

   *[[http://www.mbse.gatech.edu/education/|Georgia Tech  - ME/ISyE 8803 MBSE with SysML, McGinnis ,  ME 6105  M&S in Design, Paredis ]]
   *[[http://bulletin.lmu.edu/selp-675.htm|Loyola Marymount Los Angeles - SELP  530 & 675 Systems Architecting & Modeling  I & II,  Ghashghai, Tang & Williamson    ]]
   *[[http://web-app.usc.edu/soc/20131/sae|USC - SAE 547 Model Based Systems Architecting and Engineering,  Madni & Rosenberg]]

==== Other External Links ====

   *[[http://www.ncoic.org/|NCOIC:  Network Centric Operations Industry Consortium]]
   *[[https://www.ncoic.org/technology/activities/education/ncat/| NCOIC Network Centric Assessment Tool]]
   *[[https://www.ncoic.org/technology/activities/education/scope/| NCOIC SCOPE]]
   *[[http://www.sosece.org/| System of Systems Engineering Cemter of Excellence]]
   *[[http://www.sose2011.org/|IEEE System of Systems Engineering]]
   *[[http://www.google.com/patents?id=KF6_AAAAEBAJ&printsec=abstract#v=onepage&q&f=false|System of Elements Patent]]

=== External Wiki Articles ===
^Wiki Link^Description^
|[[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Updm|UPDM]]|Unified Profile for DoDAF/MODAF|
|[[http://www.omgwiki.org/SoaML/doku.php|SoaML]]|Service Oriented Architecture Modeling Language|
|[[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BPMN|BPMN]]|Business process Modeling Notation|
|[[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DODAF|DoDAF]]|Department of Defense Architecture Framework|
|[[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MODAF|MODAF]]|Ministry of Defence Architecture Framework|
|[[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/System_of_systems|SoS]]|System of Systems|
|[[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Systems_engineering|SE]]|Systems Engineering|
|[[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zachman_Framework|ZF]]|Zachman Framework|
|[[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TOGAF|TOGAF]]|The Open Group Architecture Framework|
|[[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atam|ATAM]]|Architecture Tradeoff Analysis Mehtod|
|[[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quality_attributes|QA]]|Quality Attributes|


===== List of Issues / Opportunities =====

  * Form core membership and initiate active participation
  * Define baseline for focus areas
  * Wiki updates by membership
  * Reachout to other INCOSE Working Groups
  * Reachout to other organizations (NDIA, NCOIC, etc.)
  * Define common terms
  * Build a list of references and bibliography


===== Bibliography =====

  * Crossley, W.A., System-of-Systems:, Introduction of Purdue University Schools of Engineering's Signature Area.
  * DeLaurentis, D. “Understanding Transportation as a System of Systems Design Problem,” 43rd AIAA Aerospace Sciences Meeting, Reno, Nevada, January 10-13, 2005. AIAA-2005-0123
  * Held, J.M., The Modelling of Systems of Systems, PhD Thesis, University of Sydney, 2008
  * Rechtin, E, System Architecting: Creating and Building Complex Systems, Prentice Hall, 1991
  * Yaneer Bar-Yam and others, The Characteristics and Emerging Behaviors of System-of-Systems in: NECSI: Complex Physical, Biological and Social Systems Project, January 7, 2004.


===== Blogs =====

  * [[http://asmarterplanet.com/blog/2010/03/the-internet-of-things.html | IBM The Internet of Things]]

===== Utube Videos =====

  * [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h2br2_twHfw&noredirect=1 | IBM System of Systems Video]]
  * [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pK-0enixGa4&feature=related | M61 System of Systems Video]]
  * [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pqXm2fHzPUw |  UPDM - IBM Rhapsody Part 1]]
  * [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=beQ2ffgpZjc |  UPDM - IBM Rhapsody Part 1]]

===== Terms and Definitions =====

  * **Architecture**:  The activity of designing any kind of system
  * **Architecture Framework**:  An architecture framework establishes a common practice for creating, interpreting, analyzing and using architecture descriptions within a particular domain of application or stakeholder community
  * **Enterprise Architecture**:  Enterprise Architecture is the continuous practice of describing the essential elements of a sociotechnical organization, their relationships to each other and to the environment, in order to understand complexity and manage change
  * **Meta Model**:  Defines the language and processes from which to form a model
  * **Meta Model**:  A model is a representation containing the essential structure of some object or event in the real world
  * **System**: A group of interacting, interrelated, or interdependent elements forming a complex whole   
  * **System of Systems**:  a class of problems that have unique characteristics, distinguishing them from “classic” systems, for example, unbounded context and usage, potentially emergent behaviors, large number of complex interactions, costly to fully verify and validate a priori
MBSE Wiki

User Tools

Site Tools

Page Tools
