Ontology Definition Metamodel (ODM) Finalization Task Force (FTF) 2

The mission of this task force is to address issues or problems found with the Ontology Definition Metamodel Beta 2 document <http://www.omg.org/cgi-bin/doc?ptc/07-09-09> and produce a report describing changes that will be used to finalize the ODM specification.

Telecons will occur on the following day and time:

• Wednesday at 1700 UTC(GMT) / 12noon Eastern / 9AM Pacific

• US/Canada Toll Free: 866-469-3239
• US/Canada Toll: 650-429-3300
• Germany Toll Free: 0800-101-6943
• Germany Toll: 49 (0) 695007 3857
• UK Toll Free: 0800-028-8023
• UK Toll: 44 (0) 207 365 1860
• China - North Toll Free: 10-800-712-1281
• China - North Toll: (none)
• Singapore Toll Free: 800-120-4239
• Singapore Toll: 65 64155103
• Elsewhere: (See WebEx popup)

574 572 712

ODMftf2

• 28 May 2008

• 17 October 2007
• 24 October 2007
• 31 October 2007
• 7 November 2007
• 14 November 2007

• 23 January 2008
• 30 January 2008
• 6 February 2008
• 13 February 2008
• 20 February 2008
• 27 February 2008
• 5 March 2008
• 13 March 2008, OMG Technical Meeting (Washington, D.C.), ODM FTF2 F2F Meeting
  1. SRI Issues, RDF/OWL Profiles, from email of 12 March 2008 and in-line meeting notes
  2. Sandpiper RDF/OWL Profile Workarounds - selected list and notes

• 2 April 2008
• 9 April 2008
• 16 April 2008
• 23 April 2008
• 7 May 2008
• 14 May 2008
• 28 May 2008
• 4 June 2008
• 13 June 2008

• 26 June 2008, OMG Technical meeting (Ottawa, CA), ODM FTF2 F2F Meeting
  1. revised issues spreadsheet (see below)
  2. meeting notes, including summary/prioritization of remaining open issues

• 9 July 2008

The content in this section that formerly documented the history and results of ODM FTF1 has moved to a separate FTF1-Archive page.

• Spreadsheet odm_ftf_issue_summary_2008-08-29.xls
• Spreadsheet odm_ftf_issue_summary_2008-07-25.xls
• Spreadsheet odm_ftf_issue_summary_2008-06-26.xls
• Spreadsheet odm_ftf_issue_summary_2008-04-18a.xls
• Spreadsheet odm_ftf_issue_summary_2008-04-18.xls
• Spreadsheet odm_ftf_issue_summary_2008-04-03.xls

• [none pending]

• One-page template for issues with disposition resolved (for FTF report) template

CLOSED - addressing issues: 10848, 10851, 10859 and 10878 All resolutions Accepted

• 10848 proposed resolution slightly revising text about the 4 M-levels WordPDF
• 10851 proposed resolution revising text eliminating “implementation” WordPDF
• 10859 proposed resolution eliminating paragraph about names as instances WordPDF
• 10878 proposed resolution revising discussion about property restrictions WordPDF

Poll 1 closed 14 March 2008

CLOSED - addressing issues: 10869, 10880-10883, 10896 and 10903 All resolutions accepted

• proposed resolution for issue 10869 (Naries) decoupling n-ary and Association Class in mapping discussion Word pdf
• proposed resolution for issues 10880 (Constants) and 10882 (Transitive closure) including UML in the language feature discussed and regrouping related text Word pdf
• proposed resolution for issue 10881 (Herbrand Semantics) making the text consistent and correct w.r.t. UML Word pdf
• proposed resolution for issue 10883 (All/SomeValuesFrom) correcting mapping for OWL Restriction constructors Word pdf
• proposed resolution for issue 10896 (Behavioral Features) constraining the UML features characterized as being dynamic Word pdf
• proposed resolution for issue 10903 (Symmetric) removing an incorrect mapping to Symmetric properties in OWL Word pdf

Poll 2 closed 30 April 2008

Closed : All resolutions accepted - Proposing resolutions related to the RDF and OWL Profile that address:

• Issue 12386 by proposing min Multiplicity of 1 for uriRef Property on RDFSDatatype MSWord pdf
• Issue 12387 by proposing simplified constraint text for RDFisDefinedBy MSWord pdf
• Issue 12388 by proposing simplified constraint text for RDFSseeAlso MSWord pdf
• Issue 12389 by proposing corrected text for mapping rdf:type to the relation between an instance specification and its classifier MSWord pdf
• Issue 12391 by proposing the UML::AssociationClass as an additional base class for stereotype «OWLAnnotation» MSWord pdf
• Issue 12392 by proposing movement of URIReferenceNode section to RDFStatments section MSWord pdf
• Issue 12393 by proposing to remove incorrect String typing from the uriRef property in the URIReferenceNode section MSWord pdf
• Issue 12395 by proposed change in text to clarify that both OWL and RDF properties denote sets MSWord pdf
• Issue 12396 by proposing to fix specified base classes for owl:Property and owl:ObjectProperty to match owl:DatatypeProperty MSWord pdf
• Issue 12397 by proposing to add a stereotype of «owlIndividual» to the OWL profile MSWord pdf

Poll 3 closed at 23:59 PT 19 May 2008

Vote completed: Resolution passed - Proposed resolution related to the RDF and OWL Profile that addresses:

• Issue 12398 by proposing use of UML::Class to reify rdf:property and owl properties. pdf MSWord

Poll 4 closed at 23:59 PT 11 August 2008

Vote passed - Proposed resolution for RDF metamodel that addresses:

• Issue 12793 regarding conflation of rdf:Statement and triple in the metamodel by proposing to separate Triple from Statement, and Named Graph from RDF Graph. The proposal is detailed in pdf MSWord .

Poll 5 closed at 16:00 EDT 25 August 2008

Vote passed - wrap up for remaining pending issues for ODM FTF2

• Issue 10843: regarding subtyping OWL Class requires OWL Full - propose close issue, no change pdf file documenting proposal

• Issues 10844: Figure D.3 notation and 10846: Annex D.4 sets - defer to RTF

• Issue 10845: Annex D.4 typo - change as requested pdf file documenting change

• Chapter 16 issues (non-normative chapter) 10849, 10850, 10853, 10863-10867, 10871-10877, 10879, 10884-10895, 10897-10902, 10904-10917 - defer to RTF

• 11099: Constraints in the RDF Metamodel Chapter (10) should be specified in OCL - defer to RTF
• 11100: Constraints in the OWL Metamodel Chapter (11) should be specified in OCL - defer to RTF

• 11102: Mapping from Common Logic to OWL should be revised - defer to rtf

• 11107: Set value for annotation property in UML profile for OWL - merge with 12391 pdf file documenting merge

• 11320: Thing in the Profile - defer to RTF

• 11321: RDFSContainer-MembershipProperty - defer to rtf

pdf file enumerating issues deferred to RTF by Poll6

Poll 6 closed at 17:00 EDT 25 August 2008

http://www.omg.org/issues/odm-ftf.open.html

http://www.omg.org/techprocess/meetings/schedule/ODM_FTF_2.html

http://www.omg.org/archives/odm-ftf/

FTF1 Archive

Report Template for MS Word

Tutorial Slides in PDF format

Specification Template for FrameMaker(MIF)

P & P Version 2.6