User Tools

Site Tools


sysml-autoview:se_material


Auto-View Generation Working Group home page - Requirements - Use Cases and Scenarios



This page is a rough draft.

Architectural Decisions

*view centric over document centric → views and viewpoints over documents and sections *method - > reproducible *viewpoint composition → *libraries - > reusability

Assessment of SysML 1.3 Against View-Viewpoint

*Write up general issue of scalability viewpoint methods aren't executable import not scalable. issue is how to specify the argument (model elements as input to) the viewpoint method *** describe alternatives: method library vs viewpoint library

Priorities

PriorityIssueDescriptionRationalePossible FixesNotes
NowProperty OrderingSysML lacks ordering of part properties within multiplicitiesTBDTBDcant order individual elements of the multiplicity. cant constraint the multiplicity property. UML spec allows for property order so this is maybe a tool bug rather that UML/SysML issue
NowViewpoint Model ELements Are Tagsviewpoint properties are tags - > need ot be propsTBDTBDTBD
NowMethods are not behaviorsThe Viewpoint Method is a simple tag. It needs to become a classifier behavior.TBDTBDTBD
NowQuery Instead of Importview imports elements from model. This is not scalable. TBDTBDConsider replacing 'view imports model elements' with 'view queries model'. (cldelp-This could also be Viewpoint Queries.)
NowDiagrams should be allowed to be ViewsCurrently diagrams are not defined as views. It should be possible to distinguish between diagrams that are views and diagrams that are just diagramsTBDTBDTBD
FutureTBDcomposition of behavior classes and blocks not clear. need to be able to compose parametric constraints onto behaviorsTBDTBDTBD
FutureTBDno way to make a relationship such that a parameter is set to be assigned a model elementTBDTBDTBD
FutureTBDno way to set a trajectory of specific valuesTBDTBDTBD
FutureTBDview is expressed in terms of one to many artifacts such as diagrams, tables, etc. TBDTBDconsidering adding a concept of a view artifact, where a view is composed of view artifacts
TBDTBDTBDTBDTBDTBD

Principles

PrincipleDefinitionRationaleImpact
parsimonyTBDTBDTBD
grounded in fundamentals of MBSE - wymoreTBDTBDTBD

Qualities

Quality AttributeDescriptionMetricNotes
expressivity/communicabilityTBDTBDTBD
extendabilityTBDTBDTBD
composabilityTBDTBDTBD
reproducibilityTBDTBDTBD

View Generation Notes

From Cory Casanave in an email to Len Levine on December 7, 2012: The following is the in-progress definitions being developed as part of the MDA guide:

View and Viewpoint A viewpoint specifies a reusable set of criteria for the construction, selection, and presentation of a portion of the information about a system, addressing particular stakeholder concerns. The by far most widely used construct since 1976 is the SQL view construct.

A view is a representation of a particular system that conforms to a viewpoint. We could, for example, have a view representing the security concerns of a payroll system.

For example, if we are creating a model information of a system that shares information there may be views for:

  • The meaning of the information to be shared
  • How the information is to be structured when shared
  • What information is to be shared with whom and under what conditions
  • The protocol by which the information consumer requests or is sent the information
  • What technology is used to actually transmit the information (in a technology model, not in a conceptual model)
  • How the information is protected during transmission
  • How we identify the parties involved
  • How the shared information is derived from our internal data

Note that the above views are interrelated, that is there are connections between them that are contained in the ground level, the model and the metamodel but that may or may not be visible in any one viewpoint.

—editorial— While not specifically addressed, I think the intent is that a diagram is part of (could be all of) a view and that a diagram type is part of (could be all of) a viewpoint.

-Cory

sysml-autoview/se_material.txt · Last modified: 2013-03-12 18:49 by araher